Skip to content

Sarah Ditum

Writing, etc.

  • Politics
  • Feminism
  • Gender
  • Books
    • All the books I read, by year
  • Other
    • Videogames
    • Film
    • Fiction
    • How to…

Unreconstructed

17 January, 2010 ~ Sarah Ditum

Naomi Klein dismantles Obama the superbrand in yesterday’s Guardian. “[His] preference for symbols over substance, and […] unwillingness to stick to a morally clear if unpopular course, is where Obama decisively parts ways with the transformative political movements from which he has borrowed so much,” she writes, itemising “the pop-art branding from Che, his cadence from King, his ‘Yes we can!’ slogan from migrant farmworkers.”

Klein predicts than “bitter cynicism” will emerge as Obama fails to deliver on the optimism he inspired, and another report in the Guardian suggests that this is already happening: Obama’s approval rating has dipped calamitously since election, reports Gary Younge. The left-wing rhetoric has distressed opponents; the compromised achievements have disappointed allies. Shepard Fairey, who designed the screen-print image of Obama, has since updated it as “Hopeless Escalation”. Sad faces all round.

Shepard Fairey’s previous big project was the Obey Giant campaign – a series of pop-art graphics of Andre the Giant with the word “obey” issued as stickers to be slapped all over the place. The “Manifesto” from 1990 asserts that his purposes were mostly playful (“The sticker has no meaning but exists only to cause people to react, to contemplate and search for meaning in the sticker”), but also presents it as a sort of anti-brand:

Because people are not used to seeing advertisements or propaganda for which the product or motive is not obvious, frequent and novel encounters with the sticker provoke thought and possible frustration, nevertheless revitalizing the viewer’s perception and attention to detail.

Obey Giant, “Manifesto”

But the Giant stickers became their own product and the brand of Fairey’s work. That’s not a slaying criticism of them – it’s just that anyone who was drawn to them because they saw them as subversive anti-marketing is going to be disappointed. The language of images gives a meaning to anything that shows up: it’s impossible to undermine it from the outside, even if a project like Obey can show its workings.

Klein, in a more sympathetic paragraph, suggests a similar systems-based explanation for Obama’s failure to reinvent American politics: “Obama is a gifted politician with a deep intelligence and a greater inclination towards social justice than any leader of his party in recent memory. If he cannot change the system in order to keep his election promises, it’s because the system is utterly broken.” So maybe Obama is another Obey, and apparent outsider whose entry into the system only shows its efficiency in accommodating all elements.

Semantic systems can be viewed as organic and inevitable, but political systems aren’t: they’re manufactured things, and they could be manufactured to avoid recreating the “dull old shapes of poverty and war”. Because the alternative – the idea that  violence and iniquity are the inevitable best we can do – is almost too depressing to go on with.

Text © Sarah Ditum, 2010

Share this:

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Email
  • Share on Tumblr
Posted in Uncategorized Barack ObamaNaomi KleinNo LogoShepard Fairey

Post navigation

< Previous [The Guardian] Do It Yourself And Save
Next > The Paperhouse guide to free speech

About me

I’m a columnist, critic and feature writer with bylines at the New Statesman, the Guardian, the Spectator, the Independent, Eurogamer, Stylist, Grazia, Elle and more. Regular TV and radio appearances, including Newsnight and Today. Available for teaching and talks. Anti-fun feminist. Represented by Juliet Pickering at Blake Friedman.

Email: sarah@sarahditum.com.

Subscribe to The Stacks, my weekly newsletter.

@sarahditum

  • RT @CareyCallsBS: Maybe if a kid isn’t mature enough to dilate on their own they’re too young to decide to get genital surgery that require… 1 hour ago
  • I really really need crumbs of hope at the moment and @VictoriaPeckham on the vaccine rollout is a whole slice of c… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 hour ago
  • Reading @rafaelbehr describe having a heart attack, I'm 1. enormously happy he recognised it and got medical attent… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 hour ago
  • In answer to the headline on this article by @StuartJRitchie - turns out I did not really know how covid spreads an… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 22 hours ago
  • Watched the Netflix Night Stalker documentary last night, and this isn't the most important bit, but wt actual f is… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 day ago
Follow @sarahditum

Latest posts

  • The Stage (only they unpublished it like cowards) | The Old Vic has made an incomprehensible decision about toilets, and women are angry about it 7 October, 2019
  • Speech: the power of feminist writing 30 May, 2019
  • Trans drama Butterfly is rejection and sexism dressed up as social justice TV 27 October, 2018
  • Six years in the gender wars 10 September, 2018
  • All the books I read in 2017, part 2 (July-December) 29 December, 2017

Search

Archives

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blog at WordPress.com.
Cancel
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.